Seaforth Primary debaters capture national junior championship

Seaforth Primary’s young debaters have secured the Junior Debate International Experience championship, finishing ahead of more than 30 schools in the national competition. The St. Thomas team included Shenoya Pratt, Jamila Berg, Romaine McGiven and Rafique Barito, with Mekisha Brown and Jordian Campbell-Lane serving as coaches.

Team members and coaches described the victory as a source of elation and pride, but said maintaining a consistent practice schedule was their greatest obstacle. Some students occasionally tried to avoid sessions or offered excuses, while Rafique repeatedly encouraged his teammates to join calls and continue preparing. He participated remotely from another country during the television interview.

Rafique said another major hurdle was helping the speakers connect emotionally with their material. Effective debating required more than reading prepared remarks, he explained, comparing the necessary performance to “auditioning for JCDC”.

Preparation also coincided with PEP and graduation activities. The students therefore had to divide their attention among examinations, graduation rehearsals and debate training. Campbell-Lane said getting them to remain after school was especially difficult because some would hide or leave for home. Rafique frequently contacted teammates and their parents to remind them about practice.

Romaine said debating strengthened her public-speaking ability. She had initially been uncomfortable addressing crowds, but participation in the competition helped her become less shy.

For Shenoya, the most difficult motion concerned whether capital punishment should be abolished. Her team had to oppose abolition, although she said 70 per cent of the world supported ending capital punishment and 30 per cent did not. She credited the coaches with helping the team conduct the required research.

Jamila said she initially doubted that Seaforth Primary would win because the opposing team had performed strongly. She was delighted when the judges announced the result, particularly because the team represented St. Thomas.

The coaches now intend to establish a debate club at Seaforth Primary. The school currently trains students specifically for competitions without operating a formal club, but other pupils have already expressed interest and asked how they can register.

Reflecting on his development, Rafique said debating gradually removed his shyness. He was nervous during the first round but felt more confident by his second appearance.